What should you do right after a key breaks in the lock?
Stop. Don't turn the remaining piece, don't push the broken half deeper, and don't reach for pliers and a paperclip. Most broken keys come out cleanly if the cylinder hasn't been forced. The damage that turns a simple extraction into a lock replacement usually happens in the first few minutes after the snap, when someone tries to fix it alone.
If part of the key still sticks out of the keyway, leave it unless it slides out with no force at all. If the broken edge is flush with the face of the cylinder, leave that too. Take a photo with your phone if you can. It helps us picture the situation when you call (213) 577-1366, and a real person answers at any hour.
- Don't try to turn the lock with the broken piece. That can bend pins or jam the plug.
- Don't glue the key back together. Glue that reaches the keyway is the one mistake that can turn an extraction into a full lock replacement.
- Don't hammer, pry, or kick at the door, and don't force a car ignition with a screwdriver.
- Do keep the broken half of the key. Even a snapped blade tells us exactly how the replacement should be cut.
- Do tell us which lock it is: front door, deadbolt, security screen door, garage side door, padlock, gate, mailbox, or a vehicle.
Why do keys break inside locks?
Keys rarely snap out of nowhere. Brass wears with every use, and a key that has been in a pocket or on a ring for years develops tiny fatigue cracks, usually near the shoulder or at the thinnest part of the blade. One extra bit of resistance is all it takes to finish the job.
Resistance is the real culprit most of the time. A lock that has gone stiff from old lubricant, dirt, or worn internal parts asks the key to do work it was never meant to do. A door that has swollen or dropped on its hinges makes the bolt bind against the strike, so you lean on the key to throw the bolt, and the key gives way before the lock does. Keys that are copies of copies are weaker still, because each generation can be cut a little off from the original.
Knowing the cause matters, because pulling the fragment out is only half the job. If we take the key out and the lock is still stiff, the next key will break too. That is why we check the lock after every extraction instead of handing you a clean keyway and leaving.
Locked out or need a locksmith now?
We answer around the clock, every day of the year.
Call (213) 577-1366How does broken key removal work, step by step?
The method depends on how the key broke and how deep the piece sits. Here is the usual sequence, whether it's a front door, a deadbolt, or a padlock.
- You call and we ask a few direct questions: which lock, how much of the key is visible, whether the lock was sticking beforehand, and for a vehicle, the make, model, and year.
- We come to you in a mobile van, or, for a padlock or a lock you can take off the door, you can bring it to our storefront at 10740 Wilshire Blvd in Westwood.
- We look into the keyway with a light and see where the key sheared: at the shoulder, mid-blade, or deep among the pins. That tells us which approach is least likely to harm the lock.
- We use thin extractor tools and hooks made for this work to catch the cuts of the broken key and draw it out along the keyway. When the fragment is wedged or sits behind the pins, we may need to take the cylinder apart so we can free it from the back.
- We test the lock before we call it done. The plug should turn smoothly, the pins and springs should be intact, and the bolt should move without binding.
- We explain what we found. If the lock is healthy we can cut a new key to match. If it is worn or damaged, we tell you what repair or replacement makes sense, and you decide before any work beyond the extraction begins.
What about a broken car key or a key snapped in the ignition?
Broken car key extraction is the same idea with different complications. A blade can snap in a door lock, which is a lot like a house lock. It can also snap in the ignition, where the cylinder is tied into the steering column and the starting system, and where forcing things costs real money.
Many modern car keys carry more than a cut blade. Whether a replacement for a broken key can be cut and made to work on the spot depends on the specific vehicle, and we don't guess about that over the phone. We confirm by VIN and in person, then tell you plainly what your car needs. For some vehicles the dealer is the only source for certain keys or programming, and if yours is one of them, we say so rather than let you wait for a job we can't finish.
If the key broke in the ignition, don't keep trying to start the car and don't pull with pliers. A worn ignition cylinder is often the reason the key broke, so we look at the cylinder itself. If it needs work, that falls under ignition repair. If you need a new key afterward, we cover that under car key replacement, and we'll tell you up front what it involves for your vehicle.
Locked out or need a locksmith now?
We answer around the clock, every day of the year.
Call (213) 577-1366What affects the cost of broken key extraction?
We don't quote numbers on a web page, because the honest answer depends on the lock in front of us. These are the things that move the cost up or down, so you know what to expect when you call:
- How deep the fragment sits. A piece sticking out of the keyway is usually a lighter job than one lodged behind the pins.
- The lock itself. A standard house cylinder, a high-security cylinder, a padlock, and a car ignition are different amounts of work.
- Whether the lock survives. If the cylinder is undamaged, extraction may be all you need. If it is worn out or was damaged by forced attempts, replacing it can be the more economical route over time.
- What comes after. A new key cut from the broken pieces, a rekey, or a repair each add to the work beyond the extraction.
- Vehicle or door. A key in a car ignition can involve more steps than one in a door lock, and some vehicles need extra verification.
- Time and place. After-hours calls and distance from our base can affect the final cost, and we explain that before we start.
Why call Wilshire Lock & Key for a broken key?
We've been in business since 1987, and broken keys are one of the oldest problems in this trade. Our work is built around a storefront at 10740 Wilshire Blvd in Los Angeles plus mobile service vans, so there is a real shop behind the van that shows up at your door, and a place to bring a lock if it needs bench work.
We are one company. Your call goes to us, not to a call center that sells the job to whoever is closest. David, the owner and lead technician, oversees the work, which matters on a job like this, where the difference between a clean extraction and a ruined cylinder is patience and the right tool.
One more thing worth knowing: California requires locksmith companies to hold a BSIS LCO license. Ask any locksmith who shows up at your door to show it before work starts. It is a reasonable request and a good way to avoid the operators who answer a local number and then send whoever is available.
Broken key help in Lawndale and ZIP 90260
Lawndale is a compact city of modest 1940s and 1950s single-family homes on small lots, many with rear units or converted garages. Each of those doors has its own lock and its own key, and much of the hardware dates to earlier decades. Old cylinders collect wear, and keys that have been copied for years break more easily. Security screen doors are common on older stock, which means a key can snap in the screen door lock or in the main lock behind it. We check both.
Climate plays a part, too. Lawndale sits a few miles inland on the coastal plain, inside the marine layer belt. Damp mornings and summer afternoon heat make older wood doors swell and stick, and a stuck door is exactly when someone leans on the key and it breaks. If your door has been tight lately, tell us. We'll look at the door as well as the lock, so the next key doesn't snap too.
Garden-style apartment buildings and small complexes line the Hawthorne Boulevard corridor and the other major streets, including the Redondo Beach Boulevard and Artesia Boulevard corridors. A key snapped in a unit door or a shared entry is a common call. If you are locked out because of it, our apartment lockout service covers that side of the problem, and property managers with duplexes and shared gates can talk with us about locksmith service for landlords.
Vehicles are the other half of Lawndale. Around the El Camino College commuter area and near Alondra Park, cars sit in lots and on streets all day, and a key that gives way in a door lock or ignition leaves you stranded in place. We come to the car. Whether you are in 90260 near El Camino Village, along the Inglewood Avenue corridor, or on Hawthorne near Redondo Beach Boulevard, we're about 16 miles from our Westwood storefront, and the mobile locksmith vans do the driving.
Locked out or need a locksmith now?
We answer around the clock, every day of the year.
Call (213) 577-1366What happens after the broken key is out?
Getting the fragment out is the emergency. What you do next depends on the lock. If it turns smoothly and the pins are intact, we can cut a new key from the pieces or from the code, and you are done. You may also want a spare or two, so the next key doesn't have to be a copy of one that is already worn. Our key duplication work covers that.
If the lock was already failing, a new key will only break the way the old one did. In that case we'll show you what we found and suggest lock repair if the lock is worth saving. If the broken key was your only copy, or you aren't sure who else holds one, a lock rekey means any old key stops working.
When is extraction not the right call?
Sometimes pulling the key is not the best use of your money. If a cheap or badly worn lock has already been forced, scarred, or filled with glue, a replacement cylinder is often the more economical route, because extraction would eat time without leaving you with a lock you can trust.
The same goes for a vehicle ignition that has failed. If the cylinder is worn through, we'd rather tell you that than extract the key and send you away with a car that breaks another one next month. We tell you what we see, and you decide.
Frequently asked questions
Can you remove a broken key without damaging the lock?
In most cases, yes. If the cylinder hasn't been forced and the fragment isn't wedged badly, thin extractor tools can draw it out and leave the lock working. When the fragment is deep or the lock is already worn, we may need to take the cylinder apart. We check the lock after every extraction and tell you honestly what shape it's in.
Can I pull the broken key out myself with tweezers or pliers?
Only if the piece slides free with no force. Pulling or prying with pliers usually bends the key, scratches the pins, or pushes the fragment further in. Never use glue. If it doesn't move easily, stop and call (213) 577-1366.
Do you come out to Lawndale at night and on weekends?
Yes. Our phone is answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, all year, and our mobile vans serve Lawndale in 90260. Call and a real person will ask you a few questions about the lock and where you are.
A key broke in my car ignition. Can you take it out?
Often we can, but we look at the ignition cylinder first, because a worn cylinder is often why the key broke. Whether a replacement key can be made on the spot depends on the vehicle, so we confirm by VIN and in person. For some vehicles the dealer is the only source, and we'll tell you if yours is one.
Will I need a new key after you remove the broken one?
Usually yes, at least a replacement for the broken one. If the lock still works properly, we can cut a key to match. If the lock is worn, we'll recommend repair or replacement before cutting a key that may break the same way.
Does broken key extraction cost more than a regular lockout?
They are different jobs, so we don't compare them. Cost depends on how deep the fragment is, what kind of lock it is, whether the lock needs repair afterward, and the time of day. We explain what's driving the cost before any work beyond the extraction begins.
Can you extract a broken key from a padlock, gate, mailbox, or screen door?
Yes, those are all common. Padlocks and removable cylinders can also be brought to our storefront at 10740 Wilshire Blvd. For gates, mailboxes, and screen doors we come to you. Tell us which one it is when you call so we bring the right tools.
The key broke in my apartment door. Who should I call?
If you rent, tell your landlord or property manager, since they may want to know, and call us for the extraction. We will need to confirm that you live there before we open or work on the lock. If the lock is shared or part of a gate, the property manager may need to approve the work.
More locksmith help in Lawndale
Broken Key Extraction near Lawndale
Reviewed by David, Owner & Lead Technician, Wilshire Lock & Key — in the locksmith trade since 1987.
Last updated 2026-10-11.
