What should you do first when a key breaks in the lock?
Stop. That is the most useful advice we can give, and it is the part people skip when they are frustrated. A key that has snapped off with part of it still showing is usually a straightforward removal. A key that has been pushed deeper, jammed with a second key, or glued is a much harder one. Most of the trouble we see on a broken key call was made worse in the first ten minutes after the break, not by the break itself.
If you can see a piece of the key sticking out of the lock, resist the urge to grab it with pliers. Pliers crush the blade, shear it flush with the face of the cylinder, or twist the pins inside. If nothing is showing, the situation is not hopeless, but it does need real extractor tools and good light.
Here is what helps and what hurts while you wait for us.
- Do keep the broken half of the key. We can sometimes use it to cut a replacement, and it shows us the exact key profile.
- Do keep the cylinder as still as you can. Do not keep turning the lock hoping it will give.
- Do not use super glue to reattach the pieces. Glue in a keyway is one of the hardest problems to undo.
- Do not push the broken piece further in with a screwdriver, a nail, or another key.
- Do not spray heavy oils or grease into the lock. A small amount of dry graphite is fine afterward, but a wet mess makes extraction harder.
- Do tell us what the key was for: a front door, a deadbolt, a padlock, a car door, a trunk, or an ignition.
Why do keys break off inside locks?
A key almost never breaks without a reason. The most common one is wear. A key that has been duplicated from a duplicate, and then used for years, develops a thinned and weakened blade. Eventually it fatigues at the shoulder or in the middle of the cut section, usually at the exact moment you turn it against some resistance.
The second reason is resistance in the lock itself. Older locksets collect dirt, dried lubricant, and worn pins, and the cylinder stops turning smoothly. The key takes the strain instead. Add a door that has swollen slightly or a bolt that no longer lines up with its strike plate, and a perfectly good key can snap while you lean on it.
In and around Athens, many of the homes are 1930s to 1950s bungalows and small stucco houses, and plenty of them still have dated locksets that have been in service for decades. Damp winter mornings can also swell an older wood door a little, which can leave the bolt binding in the strike. If you find yourself forcing the key, that is the sign to stop and have the lock looked at before the key gives out.
Security screen doors add another source of trouble. People often fight a stiff screen door lock with the same key ring they use for the main door, putting a twist on the key at an awkward angle. If a key breaks in a screen door lock or a deadbolt behind one, the removal is the same, but the working space is tighter.
Locked out or need a locksmith now?
We answer around the clock, every day of the year.
Call (213) 577-1366How do we remove a broken key step by step?
Broken key removal is a hands-on trade skill, and the method depends on how much of the key is left and what kind of lock it is in. Here is the general sequence we follow, whether we are at your door or at the storefront on Wilshire Boulevard in Westwood.
- We look at the situation first: which lock, how much of the key shows, whether the key was forced, and whether the lock was already acting up. This takes a moment and saves time later.
- If part of the key sticks out, we grip it with fine tools made for the job and draw it straight out along the keyway, without twisting the cylinder.
- If the key is broken flush or recessed, we use thin extractor tools that hook onto the cuts of the blade. We work the piece out gently so the pins inside do not get scarred.
- If the piece is jammed or the lock is binding, we adjust our approach, sometimes easing the plug slightly so the key piece frees up. We choose the method that protects the cylinder rather than the one that is quickest.
- Once the key is out, we check the keyway for fragments, burrs, and damage. A tiny sliver left behind can cause the next jam.
- We test the lock with a good key, or a new one cut on the spot where possible. If the lock turns smoothly, you are done. If it does not, we tell you straight what it needs.
- We talk through the next step with you: a spare key, a repair, a rekey, or a replacement, so the same thing does not happen again.
What about a broken car key or a key broken in the ignition?
A broken car key extraction is the same idea with extra variables. Car locks and ignition cylinders are smaller, the key may carry a transponder or remote components, and the working space is cramped. We can remove a snapped key from a door lock, trunk lock, or ignition, and we bring the tools to your car, whether it is parked in a driveway, a lot, or at the curb.
We are careful about what we claim for individual vehicles. Whether your car needs a transponder chip programmed, how a replacement key is made, and whether that can be done on site all depend on the make, model, and year. We confirm that by VIN and in person rather than guess over the phone. If your vehicle turns out to be a dealer-only case, meaning the key or the work can only be done through the dealer, we will say so plainly instead of starting a job we cannot finish.
If the ignition cylinder itself has been damaged by the broken key or by repeated forcing, that becomes a repair question. Our page on ignition repair in Athens covers that side of things. If the key is out but you now have no working key for the car, see car key replacement.
Locked out or need a locksmith now?
We answer around the clock, every day of the year.
Call (213) 577-1366What affects the cost of broken key removal?
We do not quote numbers on a web page because the honest answer depends on the lock and the situation in front of us. What we can do is tell you which things move the cost up or down, so nothing about the quote feels like a surprise.
The biggest factor is how the key broke. A piece still sticking out of the lock is generally the lighter-cost job. A piece broken flush, pushed deep, or jammed by an earlier attempt takes more time and finer work.
The type of lock matters too. A basic residential deadbolt, a screen door lock, a high-security cylinder, a padlock, and a car ignition all behave differently and take different tools and time.
Other things that affect the price:
- The condition of the lock. A worn or dirty cylinder can fight back, and sometimes it is more sensible to rekey or replace it than to save it.
- Whether you also need a replacement key cut, and what kind of key it is.
- Whether the job is a vehicle that needs programming or other work beyond the extraction.
- The time of day and where we are traveling from. We cover a very large area from our base in Westwood, and Athens is about 15 miles from there.
- Whether the lock is damaged and needs repair or replacement after the key comes out.
What happens after the broken key is out?
Getting the piece out is only half the job. The other half is making sure it does not happen again, and that is where we try to give you honest options rather than the biggest job.
First, you need a working key. If you kept the broken half or still have an intact original, we can usually make a clean copy. Making a copy from a worn key is how weak keys get passed down, so we prefer to cut from a good original or from the lock itself. See our page on key duplication for how we approach that.
Second, we look at why the key broke. If the lock was binding, a repair is often the sensible next step, and we explain it on our lock repair page. If the cylinder is badly worn, or if you have lost track of who has copies of the old keys, a rekey is worth considering, since it makes the old keys useless and gives you fresh ones in a single visit. The details are on our lock rekey page.
Often the lighter-cost route is simply to extract the key, cut a new one, and leave a perfectly sound lock alone. We say that when it is true. We would rather you decide with accurate information than replace hardware that still works.
Locked out or need a locksmith now?
We answer around the clock, every day of the year.
Call (213) 577-1366Broken key help around Athens: neighborhoods, ZIP codes, and common situations
Athens is an unincorporated community in Los Angeles County, and we come out to both ZIP codes, 90044 and 90047. That includes Athens on the Hill, the streets around Chester Washington Golf Course, and the areas along the Vermont Avenue, El Segundo Boulevard, Imperial Highway, and Normandie Avenue corridors. We also get calls from people living near Hollypark in Gardena and near Westmont.
The housing here shapes the calls. Much of Athens is older single-family bungalows and small stucco homes on modest lots, with postwar houses near Chester Washington Golf Course. A lot of those doors still carry dated locksets, and many have a security screen door in front. A key that has been used for decades in a worn deadbolt behind a screen door is a classic setup for a snap. If that happens at your place, we can usually deal with it on the spot at the door, and then talk about whether the old hardware is worth keeping.
Small apartment buildings line Vermont Avenue and the major east-west boulevards. A key breaking in an apartment door often turns into a lockout too, since the key you would have used is the one that is stuck. We cover that overlap on our apartment lockout page, but the extraction itself is the same work. If you rent, let your landlord or property manager know, since the lock may be theirs to repair.
Along El Segundo Boulevard and Imperial Highway, storefronts see heavy daily use, and a key snapping in a shop door at opening time is a real problem. Our storefront lock repair service picks up where extraction leaves off if the lock is worn. Near Los Angeles Southwest College, we also see office doors and hardware where a key has broken, and the sooner it is cleared, the sooner the door is back in use.
The climate here is mild and the salt-air corrosion that wrecks locks near the coast is minimal. So when a lock in Athens seizes up or a key breaks, the usual cause is age, wear, a swollen door in damp winter weather, or simple force on a tired key, not corrosion. Because we work as a mobile operation, our mobile locksmith service brings the tools to you, whether you are at home, at work, or by your car.
Why call Wilshire Lock & Key for a broken key?
We have been in business since 1987, and broken keys are one of the oldest problems in this trade. We have a storefront at 10740 Wilshire Blvd in Westwood and mobile service vans, so the work is not subcontracted to whoever happens to be nearby. The company that answers your call is the company that comes out. There are no dispatch middlemen, and David, who owns the company and leads the technical work, oversees how we do it.
We serve 140 cities across Los Angeles and Ventura counties, and our phone, (213) 577-1366, is answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, year-round. A snapped key does not pick a convenient hour, so neither do we.
One more thing worth knowing: California requires locksmith companies to hold a BSIS LCO license. Whoever you hire for this, ask for it before they start work. It is a reasonable question and a good locksmith will not mind it.
If you are not sure whether your situation needs us right away, call and describe it. We will tell you honestly if it is something you can safely leave until morning or if it should be handled now.
Frequently asked questions
Can a broken key really be removed without replacing the lock?
In most cases, yes. When the key is intact enough to grip or hook, the piece can be drawn out and the lock keeps working. If the lock was already worn or the pins are damaged, we will tell you so after the key is out. Replacing the lock is only worth it when the lock itself is the problem.
I have a key broken inside the lock and nothing is sticking out. Is that fixable?
Often it is. A key broken flush or recessed takes finer extractor tools and more patience, but it is routine work for us. The one thing to avoid is pushing the piece deeper with a screwdriver or another key. Leave it alone and call us.
Is a broken key stuck in the door a lockout too?
It can be. If the broken key was your only way in, you are locked out and the lock still needs attention. We can usually clear the key and get the door open in the same visit. Our pages on house lockout and apartment lockout explain that side.
Can you extract a broken car key from the ignition?
Yes, we remove broken keys from car ignitions, door locks, and trunk locks. What you need after that, such as a new key or chip programming, depends on the vehicle, and we confirm by VIN and in person. If your car turns out to be a dealer-only case, we will tell you honestly.
Should I try using glue or pliers myself first?
No. Pliers tend to crush or shear the key, and glue in a keyway is very hard to undo. Both make a simple removal into a longer one. If you have not touched it, leave it that way and call (213) 577-1366.
Do you come to me, or do I bring the lock to you?
We come to you. Our mobile vans serve Athens and the surrounding area, and the work happens at your door, your storefront, or your car. If the lock is on a removable item, like a padlock, you are also welcome at our Westwood storefront.
How much does broken key extraction cost?
It depends on how the key broke, what kind of lock it is, the condition of the lock, and whether you also need a new key or a repair. We do not post numbers here because they would not be honest without seeing the situation. When you call, we explain what affects the cost before the work begins.
Can you make me a new key after the old one breaks?
Usually, yes. If you have the broken half or an intact original, we can cut a clean replacement. For cars, it depends on the key type and the vehicle, which we confirm in person. If you have no original at all, we can talk through options based on the lock.
Will a broken key mean I need to rekey my locks?
Not necessarily. A broken key on its own is not a reason to rekey. It becomes worth considering if the cylinder is worn out, if you want to cancel old keys that other people may have, or if the lock is failing. We will give you our honest recommendation after we see it.
More locksmith help in Athens
Broken Key Extraction near Athens
Reviewed by David, Owner & Lead Technician, Wilshire Lock & Key — in the locksmith trade since 1987.
Last updated 2026-10-11.
